Hey new mom! You’re enjoying the parenting journey! The amazing feelings to be a mom the first time! Isn’t? Of course yes. Now your first priority is to nourish your baby. Here the question of what is best for your baby breastfeeding or formulas?  Breastfeeding is always the best option at least for the first six months. Read the topic about 10 Positions and Benefits of Breastfeeding After then  90+First Baby Food That Can Be Eaten With No Teeth.

As a stay-at-home mom, it’s all easy for you to feed your baby on demand but what for working mom? It is important to think about a breast pump. SPECTRA S1 Vs S2 – Which one is the best? 

The most popular breast pumps are spectra and Medela. It considers the #1 mom breast pump and breast milk feeding products.

There are several situations that make you use the breast pump even you’re a stay-at-home mom. Like illness or any kind of treatment that makes you unable to breastfeed. Then allow your pump to feed your baby safely. After all feeding baby on the demand is very important.

These devices are super easy and handy for you

  • to embark on a journey
  • just you want to maintain your milk supply
  • You’re dealing with low supply

These are possible situations make you use breast pumps. I  made the decision after heard many moms’ opinions about spectra vs Medela breast pump. These breast pumps are super useful when babies can’t or won’t nurse themselves.

There is a wide range of breast pumps in the market to make your breastfeeding journey easy and cool, you intend on pumping exclusively or to supplement your nursing routine.

However, You can get single, double, manual and electric pumps in the market. I’m with electric pumps as these are more effective and time-efficient than a single or manual pump.

The electric pump is rhythmic and you have full controlled suction to keep your milk flowing. It’s hand free option makes the sense for the most moms.

As there is a variety of breast pumps you can find the best one that suits you. You can make an inquiry with your health insurance plan about your specific benefits and what to do to claim for your free breast pump.

Description of Spectra vs Medela via amazon with price

1.Medela Pump in Style

  • ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY FOR SUPERIOR PERFORMANCE: Thanks to its patented and research-based 2-Phase Expression Technology, mothers can produce more milk in less time; this breast pump was made for optimal efficiency and maximized flow
  • PORTABLE: Removable breast pump and battery pack allow for discreet, mobile pumping anytime  at home, at work, or on the go
  • CUSTOMIZABLE SETTINGS AND ACCESSORIES: Single knob adjustable speed and vacuum with one-touch letdown button; Set of each 24mm and 27mm size flanges allow moms to enhance their pumping experience, based on what’s most effective and comfortable
  • OVERFLOW PROTECTION: Closed system at the motor, which prevents milk from entering the motor
  • INCLUDED: Removable breast pump; Double pumping kit: 2 sizes of flanges, 2 connectors, 2 valves & membranes, 1 set of tubing; Messenger bag; Cooler bag and ice pack; (4) 5oz/150mL bottles with lids; Battery pack and pouch; Power Adaptor 110/240V; Flexible plastic workspace; (2) Mesh storage bags
One of the most popular and trusted brands is Medela. Mostly, moms use the Medela brand. Its key features are:-
  • A double pump kit with a PersonalFit breast shield
  • Operate with plugged in
  • Adjustable speed and vacuum knob
  • All parts are BPA-free
  • It includes breast shields, membrane, valves, and tubing
  • It has a removable freezer pack and cooler bag

2. Spectra s1 and s2

    • Includes Spectra S2 Hospital Grade Double/Single breast pump, 12 volt AC power adapter, detachable power cord prong, (2) It has wide neck bottle, (2) Spectra backflow protector, (2) duckbill valve, (2)  tubing, (2) 24mm flange, (2) 28mm flange
    • Closed system: No need to clean the narrow tubing because Spectra S1 has a closed pumping system that keeps tubing dry by preventing air flow between expressed milk and pump tubing while pumping protecting breast milk and baby from bacteria, mold, and viruses
    • Customizable settings: Each mother can customize her pump’s settings to her own body’s response and follow her flow to find her own best settings with the S2’s completely adjustable suction and 2 phase cycling in let-down and expression mode
    • BPA/DEHP free: All of Spectra Baby USA storage containers and parts that come in contact with breast milk are BPA/DEHP free
    • Mommy owned: Spectra Baby USA is owned and run by registered nurses, board-certified lactation consultants, and more importantly… by moms

     See more product details

    More About Spectra

    Spectra is the fast gaining product among the breastfeeding moms. There’s only one difference between the two. Apart from color, spectra s1 has a rechargeable battery.
    It depends upon you what is the best spectra vs medela. According to the features. The S1 is the best for frequent pumping that doesn’t need any power source. Spectra S1 is the best for the mom on trip and journey, working moms.
    The spectra S2 is the best for the:-
  • mom who doesn’t have any problem with pumping via electric source.
  • A mom who needs to pump a lot of breast milk
  • Spectra s2 save some money also
  • S2 is cheaper than S2

Main features of the spectra pump are:-

  • The maximum suction capacity of 280 mmHg and can adjust the suction
  • Hospital-grade strength motor
  • BPA free parts
  • Lightweight with no noise
  • can be used as single or double breasts
  • Its digital control allows you to set rhythm and speed

I’ll suggest you for Spectra s1 as it has a battery and can be used without power supply. Spectra S2 can be used when plugged into a power source.

The common features between spectra vs medela pump are below:-

  • Both pumps are double electric
  • can function as a single pump also
  • They both are portable because of their battery option
  • Both have near about the same price
  • The spectra and medela are hands-free
  • You can use via breastfeeding bras and make your hands free
  • The moms can be control suction and speed

Now, what are differences between spectra vs medela:-

Open vs Closed system:-
  • Medela Pump In Style Advanced (PISA) has an open system and Spectra S1 is a closed system pump
  • S1 has a way to keep milk from entering the motor but medela doesn’t have any barrier
  • The Spectra S1 is more hygienic and doesn’t effect on motor performance
  • A closed system pump is more sanitary while an open system pump requires to constantly sterilize the tubes
  • Both pumps are portable and can run on the battery
  • S1 comes with a built-in rechargeable battery but medela has a AA batteries
Health Concern:-
  • Medela has a PISA that allows the backflow of milk and causes moisture. It is not good and leads tp molds growing in the tube.
  • Spectra S1 is a close system pump. So, it is good sign nourishment for the baby.
  • Spectra S1 is the most powerful breast pump. It is a hospital grade trusted brand
  • It helps to stabilize the breast milk supply
  • Start with a massage while nursing. You get better results.
  • S1 has a maximum suction strength of 280 mmHg. Medela pump has a maximum of 250 mmHg

Other features that can’t be neglected about Spectra S1 parts are not available in the local stores. You can get via Amazon only.

One complaint about medela PISA is that the suction cause sore nipples and painful pumping. You have to place the right flange on the nipples to avoid pain. Spectra S1 is more gentle, comfortable and more efficient while pumping.


Medela PISA Pros

  • Parts are easily available
  • It’s a good adapter and ideal for trips
  • Medela comes with many accessories- cooler with an ice pack, tote bag, and 4 bottles.
  • Flange and shields are easy to clean

Medela PISA Cons

  • Open system pump
  • The Suction ability is less than hospital-grade pumps
  • It is a bit noisy
  • heavy in weight

Spectra S1 Pros

  • Closed system
  • Affordable price
  • Gentle
  • Portable
  • Less noisy
  • light-weighted
  • It includes a Nightlight mode

Spectra S1 Cons

  • Inferior quality bottles
  • Not available in the US market for so long
  • Parts are not available in the stores
  • Bottles have an inferior quality
  • It comes with only one Flange and shields, making cleaning more difficult

It is very difficult to say which one the better between spectra vs medela. Breast pumps have the ability to make breastfeeding easier for new moms.


Spectra vs medela both have the combination of power pumping strength, digital control, less noise and provide comfort while nursing. It’s difficult to say which one is the best.

Although, each mom has her own choice of what is best for her. You’ll be able to decide the right after considering the points Because all moms have their own preferences. Choice according to your comfortability and adorability. If you like my efforts please share it with your friend. It’ll help me to grow my little blog.